Merck3's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Primal War 16]

man

ive been following this series for a long time, and it just keeps looking better and better. i wish some of these episodes would go somewhere though, i understand that you feel you have to keep pumping them out, i just think spending a little more time and having some action in them might help. i thought this was better than some other episodes, but i still feel there was no real climax to it.

[Time in a Bottle]

brilliant

i just wish i had more time to enjoy the art. i felt myself trying to keep up with the animations. otherwise it was a stunning piece of work.

[Waterlollies]

Finally

The Master has come back with another absolutely great flash. I don't know how you do it but i love all of your flash, especially the Brackenwood. What an unbelievable talent you have.

[The adventures of Baxter]

that...

was seriously great. the animations arent the best, but it was pretty damn funny, and any dog owner can relate their dogs to that.

[Kingdom Hearts Anime pt1]

i hate to say it

but that was kind of painful. the voice acting and timing between speaking parts was really bad. the animation was just fine though. it could have been better if you took more time, like you said only two months, theres been great flash on here thats taken over a year. take your time, and do it right for 6-10 or whatever you decide to do next.

KobraEditing responds:

2 months is a very long time for me while doing an animation like this...I got so much stuff getting in the way that I would have finished this double time without it...well I am glad you liked the animation

[Primal War 14]

hmm

not my favorite in the series, seemed kind of rushed, pace wise. it is still a very good flash, though inconsistent in the quality. Any animation of the boat was very generic, and the sounds could use a bit more variety. i understand using the same growl for noth when he fights because it is the " theme sound" at the beginning of every flash in this series.
the fighting looks great, but there are a lot of parts with just still shots, especially with the princess. additionally, even though there was a fight scene and the princess became magical, not a whole lot actually happened. i felt disappointed at the end of this particular flash.
ill still give you an 8 because you can animate better than 95 percent of artists out there and the story its self has always kept me wanting to see the next flash, so i guess in that way, the "cliff hanger" ending was kind of good.
in short, anti-climactic, needs more variety in sounds, consistency in drawings needs improvement. just remember the little things count too. if the boats and other things look awkward, it makes the feel of the flash less genuine and takes the observer out of the mood and setting of the flash. im looking forward to your next installment, and good luck.

[Aladdin 3150]

to:flying guy

its this thing called an imagination. there doesnt have to be planes and scrap metal everywhere, maybe they cleaned it all up. and if you didnt notice, most the people in here are darker complected, meaning it probably takes place in a natural desert anyway. so there you go. and by the way flecko, a true piece of art. One of the better drawn flashes on newgrounds. there were a few spots that lacked detail, but as you said you were up against a deadline. i hope to see more like this in the future.